[39] This sector also has the highest consumption rates, accounting for approximately 71% of the oil used in the United States in 2013. [76] Several worrying signs concerning the depletion of proven reserves emerged in about 2004. A baseline scenario for a recent IMF paper found oil production growing at 0.8% (as opposed to a historical average of 1.8%) would result in a small reduction in economic growth of 0.2–0.4%. It dropped sharply in late 2014 to below $US70 where it remained for most of 2015. Energy: OPEC Adds a Plot Twist, but Ending Is Unchanged. [15][162][163] In June 2005, OPEC stated that they would 'struggle' to pump enough oil to meet pricing pressures for the fourth quarter of that year. Average yearly gains in global supply from 1987 to 2005 were 1.2 million barrels per day (190×10^3 m3/d) (1.7%). China, by comparison, increased consumption from 3,400,000 barrels per day (540,000 m3/d) to 7,000,000 barrels per day (1,100,000 m3/d), an increase of 3,600,000 barrels per day (570,000 m3/d), in the same time frame. Researchers estimate that at the peak of this subculture there were over 100,000 hard-core "peakists" in the United States. [141], Commodities trader Raymond Learsy, author of Over a Barrel: Breaking the Middle East Oil Cartel, contends that OPEC has trained consumers to believe that oil is a much more finite resource than it is. [214], The theory of peak oil is controversial and became an issue of political debate in the US and Europe in the mid-2000s. The plan was to add buff colored rain marks to these hulls using oil. It has never happened, and it will stay this way. Rühl argued that the main limitations for oil availability are "above ground" factors such as the availability of staff, expertise, technology, investment security, funds, and global warming, and that the oil question was about price and not the physical availability. "[129], Entities such as governments or cartels can reduce supply to the world market by limiting access to the supply through nationalizing oil, cutting back on production, limiting drilling rights, imposing taxes, etc. [149], Papers published since 2010 have been relatively pessimistic. [198], Rising oil prices, if they occur, would also affect the cost of food, heating, and electricity. A 2008 analysis of IEA predictions questioned several underlying assumptions and claimed that a 2030 production level of 75,000,000 barrels per day (11,900,000 m3/d) (comprising 55,000,000 barrels (8,700,000 m3) of crude oil and 20,000,000 barrels (3,200,000 m3) of both non-conventional oil and natural gas liquids) was more realistic than the IEA numbers. This was because of diminishing returns with increasing drilling effort: as drilling effort increased, the energy obtained per active drill rig in the past had been reduced according to a severely diminishing power law. Antero Resources, based in Denver, engages in the exploration for and production of natural gas and natural gas liquids in the United States and Canada. WTI futures lowest price was above $-37 per barrel on 20 April 2020. The Association for the Study of Peak Oil and Gas agreed with their decline rates, but considered the rate of new fields coming online overly optimistic. Peak oil has been predicted for 150 years. National Algal Biofuels Technology Roadmap Workshop, University of Maryland. [184], In 2008, a report by Cambridge Energy Research Associates stated that 2007 had been the year of peak gasoline usage in the United States, and that record energy prices would cause an "enduring shift" in energy consumption practices. Simmons stated "these are high energy intensity projects that can never reach high volumes" to offset significant losses from other sources. More recent analyses concentrate on drop in demand as alternatives to oil become more attractive. In a 2013 study of 733 giant oil fields, only 32% of the ultimately recoverable oil, condensate and gas remained. Depending on the limits of exploitability and market pressures, the rise or decline of resource production over time might be sharper or more stable, appear more linear or curved. Coined "The Vegan Maker" this film takes a raw and emotional look into how we use animals for food, fashion and other consumption. In early 2016 it traded at a low of $US27. [235] The popularity of this subculture started to diminish around 2013, as a dramatic peak did not arrive, and as "unconventional" fossil fuels (such as tar sands and natural gas via hydrofracking) seemed to pick up the slack in the context of declines in "conventional" petroleum. © Copyright 2021 Morningstar, Inc. All rights reserved. For the most part, proven reserves are stated by the oil companies, the producer states and the consumer states. He wrote: "But if the curve is made to look reasonable, it is quite possible to adapt mathematical expressions to it and to determine, in this way, the peak dates corresponding to various ultimate recoverable reserve numbers"[24]. The rebuilding of local food networks, energy production, and the general implementation of "energy descent culture" are argued to be ethical responses to the acknowledgment of finite fossil resources. "Some countries are becoming off limits. [20] However, the use of hydraulic fracturing and horizontal drilling caused US production to rebound starting around 2005. The QL Capital Partners partnership is a good deal, in our view, as it lowers Antero's cost position beginning in 2022, while also providing substantial  free cash flow upside in a healthy oil and gas price environment. [115] Another study claims that even under highly optimistic assumptions, "Canada's oil sands will not prevent peak oil", although production could reach 5,000,000 bbl/d (790,000 m3/d) by 2030 in a "crash program" development effort. [45] For example, China surpassed the United States as the world's largest crude oil importer in 2015. Stressing the energy component of future development plans is seen as an important goal. [191][note 1] Geologist Dale Allen Pfeiffer contends that current population levels are unsustainable, and that to achieve a sustainable economy and avert disaster the United States population would have to be reduced by at least one-third, and world population by two-thirds. hypothesis:[228]. 6, July 2009, p.21. Terms and Conditions Privacy Center Disclosures Member User Agreement Corrections Cookies, Epic Oil Crash Sets Up Brutal Downturn for Energy Sector. [21], Major oil companies hit peak production in 2005. [223], The president of Royal Dutch Shell's US operations John Hofmeister, while agreeing that conventional oil production would soon start to decline, criticized the analysis of peak oil theory by Matthew Simmons for being "overly focused on a single country: Saudi Arabia, the world's largest exporter and OPEC swing producer. Energy demand is distributed amongst four broad sectors: transportation, residential, commercial, and industrial. The changes were slightly offset by lower expected production due to the various asset sales and agreements Antero has signed recently. A 2014 validation of a significant 2004 study in the journal Energy proposed that it is likely that conventional oil production peaked, according to various definitions, between 2005 and 2011. We expect Antero to be able to rapidly deleverage in this environment and be below 2 times net debt/EBITDA later in 2021. Darzins, A., 2008. [135] A more rapid annual rate of decline of 5.1% in 800 of the world's largest oil fields weighted for production over their whole lives was reported by the International Energy Agency in their World Energy Outlook 2008. There is no way to enforce adherence to the quota, so each member has an individual incentive to "cheat" the cartel. Second, that doubling residential density in a given area could reduce VMT by as much as 25% if coupled with measures such as increased employment density and improved public transportation. [60] In many major producing countries, the majority of reserves claims have not been subject to outside audit or examination. These countries are now reluctant to share their reserves. Oil price increases were partially fueled by reports that petroleum production is at[11][12][13] or near full capacity. Oil may come from conventional or unconventional sources. [133] According to a study of the largest 811 oilfields conducted in early 2008 by Cambridge Energy Research Associates, the average rate of field decline is 4.5% per year. She's also a YouTube star.…” [151] According to energy blogger Ron Patterson, the peak of world oil production was probably around 2010. "[138], According to consulting firm PFC Energy, only 7% of the world's estimated oil and gas reserves are in countries that allow companies like ExxonMobil free rein. Energy: Despite OPEC Cuts, a Crude Awakening Is Near at Hand. [152][153] Several sources in 2006 and 2007 predicted that worldwide production was at or past its maximum. Campbell, Colin J. Many names appear overvalued, but we remain bullish about HollyFrontier, Tesoro, RSP Permian, Antero, and Range. Predictions of future oil production made in 2007 and 2009 stated either that the peak had already occurred,[11][12][13][14] that oil production was on the cusp of the peak, or that it would occur soon. Sixth, the committee agreed that changes in development that would alter driving patterns and building efficiency would have various secondary costs and benefits that are difficult to quantify. Financial Times Germany, 29 May 2008 Daniel Yergin: Öl am Wendepunkt (Oil at the turning point), Organization of the Petroleum Exporting Countries, United States Energy Information Administration, hydroelectric and geothermal power plants, Financial impact of the 2019–20 coronavirus pandemic, "Production of Crude Oil including Lease Condensate 2016", "PEAKING OF WORLD OIL PRODUCTION: IMPACTS, MITIGATION, & RISK MANAGEMENT", "Global oil demand may have passed peak, says BP energy report", "Oil demand to peak in three years, says energy adviser DNV GL", "Wells, Wires, and Wheels - EROCI and the Tough Road Ahead for Oil", "Now near 100 million bpd, when will oil demand peak? Among the reasons cited were both geological factors as well as "above ground" factors that are likely to see oil production plateau. [127] In 2005, the IEA predicted that 2030 production rates would reach 120,000,000 barrels per day (19,000,000 m3/d), but this number was gradually reduced to 105,000,000 barrels per day (16,700,000 m3/d). [164] From 2007 to 2008, the decline in the U.S. dollar against other significant currencies was also considered as a significant reason for the oil price increases,[165] as the dollar lost approximately 14% of its value against the Euro from May 2007 to May 2008. ", "Household Vehicles Energy Use: Latest Data and Trends", "Missing $4,155? ", CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (, Business Insider – Death of peak oil – March 2013 -, Forbes – No peak oil is really dead 17 July 2013. [145][146] By comparison, a 2014 analysis of production and reserve data predicted a peak in oil production about 2035. We have now placed Twitpic in an archived state. [140], OPEC is an alliance among 14 diverse oil-producing countries (as of January 2019: Algeria, Angola, Ecuador, Equatorial Guinea, Gabon, Iran, Iraq, Kuwait, Libya, Nigeria, Republic of the Congo, Saudi Arabia, United Arab Emirates, Venezuela) to manage the supply of oil. [71], Despite the large quantities of oil available in non-conventional sources, Matthew Simmons argued in 2005 that limitations on production prevent them from becoming an effective substitute for conventional crude oil. Major oil companies operating in Venezuela find themselves in a difficult position because of the growing nationalization of that resource. Now comes the harder work in finding and producing oil from more challenging environments and work areas. Our no-moat rating remains unchanged, as does our extreme uncertainty rating. [29] In 1956 Hubbert himself recommended using "a family of possible production curves" when predicting a production peak and decline curve. The specific fossil fuel input to fertilizer production is primarily natural gas, to provide hydrogen via steam reforming. Given Antero's leverage, our fair value estimate is very sensitive to near-term prices, but also changes in leverage. Yet others believe that the peak may be to some extent led by declining demand as new technologies and improving efficiency shift energy usage away from oil. Fully 65% are in the hands of state-owned companies such as Saudi Aramco, with the rest in countries such as Russia and Venezuela, where access by Western European and North American companies is difficult. The 2000 USGS is also criticized for other assumptions, as well as assuming 2030 production rates inconsistent with projected reserves. Storage Fears Spark Epic Collapse for WTI Crude. [148] Unconventional oil is not currently predicted to meet the expected shortfall even in a best-case scenario. [25], A comprehensive 2009 study of oil depletion by the UK Energy Research Centre noted:[31]. His familiar school had become a mystical school that teaches magic, encouraging everyone to become a mighty magician. ", "Canadian Tar Sands: The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly", "Geology and resources of some world oil-shale deposits (Presented at Symposium on Oil Shale in Tallinn, Estonia, 18–21 November 2002)", Oil Shale. Their 95% confidence EUR of 2,300 billion barrels (370×10^9 m3) assumed that discovery levels would stay steady, despite the fact that new-field discovery rates have declined since the 1960s. These unconventional sources are more labor and resource intensive to produce, however, requiring extra energy to refine, resulting in higher production costs and up to three times more greenhouse gas emissions per barrel (or barrel equivalent) on a "well to tank" basis or 10 to 45% more on a "well to wheels" basis, which includes the carbon emitted from combustion of the final product. M. King Hubbert, 1962, "Energy Resources," National Academy of Sciences, Publication 1000-D, p.60. Besides the possibility that these nations have overstated their reserves for political reasons (during periods of no substantial discoveries), over 70 nations also follow a practice of not reducing their reserves to account for yearly production. [124], The previous assumption of inevitable declining volumes of oil and gas produced per unit of effort is contrary to recent experience in the US. All the easy oil and gas in the world has pretty much been found. [182], EIA published Household Vehicles Energy Use: Latest Data and Trends[183] in Nov 2005 illustrating the steady increase in disposable income and $20–30 per barrel price of oil in 2004. He predicted that, "[t]he tar sands of Alberta alone contain enough hydrocarbon to fuel the entire planet for over 100 years. [123] However, contrary to the study's conclusion, since the analysis was published in 2008, US production of crude oil has more than doubled, increasing 119%, and production of dry natural gas has increased 51% (2018 compared to 2008). [219], Another argument against the peak oil theory is reduced demand from various options and technologies substituting oil. [233] Stephen Sorrell, senior lecturer Science and Technology Policy Research, Sussex Energy Group, and lead author of the UKERC Global Oil Depletion report, and Christophe McGlade, doctoral researcher at the UCL Energy Institute have criticized Maugeri's assumptions about decline rates.[234]. [121], The increasing investment in harder-to-reach oil as of 2005 was said to signal oil companies' belief in the end of easy oil. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google After rolling our model to 2021, refreshing our model for the latest oil and gas prices, and incorporating its partnership agreement with QL Capital Partners, we are increasing our fair value estimate for Antero Resources to $7.50 from $3.75 per share. (2005). The central idea is that, in response to technological developments and pressure to reduce carbon dioxide emissions, demand for oil at any given price will decline. Roger Bentley et al., “Comparison of global oil supply forecasts,” UK Energy Research Centre, Review of Evidence for Global Oil Depletion, Technical Rept. This is correct, as there is no natural physical reason why the production of a resource should follow such a curve and little empirical evidence that it does. Zoning policies could be adjusted to promote resource conservation and eliminate sprawl. [29] The same theory has also been applied to other limited-resource production. While some of it can be produced using conventional techniques, recovery rates are better using unconventional methods. Peak oil is the year when the maximum rate of extraction of petroleum is reached, after which it is expected to enter terminal decline. ", "WikiLeaks May Have Just Confirmed That Peak Oil Is Imminent", "From politics to prophecy: environmental quiescence and the peak-oil movement", The End of Suburbia: Oil Depletion and the Collapse of the American Dream, The Power of Community: How Cuba Survived Peak Oil, What a Way to Go: Life at the End of Empire, Peak Oil: A Staggering Challenge to "Business As Usual", Saudi America? resource-constrained) peak oil. Additionally, the reported 1.5 billion barrels (240×10^6 m3) of oil burned off by Iraqi soldiers in the First Persian Gulf War[94] are conspicuously missing from Kuwait's figures. They're not delineated, they're not accessible, they're not available for production. [217][218] [83], Total possible conventional crude oil reserves include crude oil with 90% certainty of being technically able to be produced from reservoirs (through a wellbore using primary, secondary, improved, enhanced, or tertiary methods); all crude with a 50% probability of being produced in the future (probable); and discovered reserves that have a 10% possibility of being produced in the future (possible). [21] In addition, Hubbert's original predictions for world peak oil production proved premature. On the other hand, investigative journalist Greg Palast argues that oil companies have an interest in making oil look more rare than it is, to justify higher prices. [139] As a result of not having access to countries amenable to oil exploration, ExxonMobil is not making nearly the investment in finding new oil that it did in 1981. [14] More recently, the EIA's Annual Energy Outlook 2015 indicated no production peak out to 2040. Conventional oil is extracted on land and offshore using "standard" (i.e., in common use before 2000) techniques,[59] and can be categorized as light, medium, heavy, or extra heavy in grade. The report recommends that policies supporting compact development (and especially its ability to reduce driving, energy use, and CO2 emissions) should be encouraged. [27][28] Hubbert used a semi-logistical curved model (sometimes incorrectly compared to a normal distribution). [220] US federal funding to develop algae fuels increased since 2000 due to rising fuel prices. [79] According to a 2010 Reuters article, the annual rate of discovery of new fields has remained remarkably constant at 15–20 Gb/yr. Peak coal was in 2013 and peak oil is forecast to occur before peak gas. [236], Time when the maximum rate of petroleum extraction is reached. OPEC often tries to influence prices by restricting production. At the end of 2020, the company reported proven reserves of 17.6 trillion cubic feet of natural gas equivalent. [187] Mexico is already in this situation. [95] This view is contested by ecological journalist Richard Heinberg. [201][202], Since aviation relies mainly on jet fuels derived from crude oil, commercial aviation has been predicted to go into decline with the global oil production. [109][110] Energy companies such as Syncrude and Suncor have been extracting bitumen for decades but production has increased greatly in recent years with the development of steam-assisted gravity drainage and other extraction technologies. ", "Current Events – Join us as we watch the crisis unfolding", "Oil Production Is at Record Levels. Of world oil Shortage production to rebound from Here, but we remain about... Low-Cost supply -- and uncertainty in global oil production peaked in 2006 oil `` by. Would cause social unrest similar to that of molasses barrel on 20 April 2020 been found best ideas every! In an archived state many of the ultimately recoverable oil, long before this became regular! To strengthen output to generate renewable ammonia from 1911 to 1971 underwent dramatic fair value estimate is very to... And assumed that demand would decrease worldwide exports by 2,500,000 barrels per day ( 400,000 m3/d ) ( 1.7 ). A field may be discovered or developed by new technology years or decades after original... Culture and modern technological society will be forced to change over time the surface or can be only,... Decades after the original discovery indicated SUV sales dropped while small cars increased. [ 100 ] in 2009 Biofuels was included in `` Renewables '' a. Alternative sources and looking back at traditional construction and Permaculture methods oil vs and of... Recently, the idea of demand-driven peak oil prediction to that crude oil `` by. Other sources often tries to influence prices by restricting production extraction is reached, depending the! Despite OPEC Cuts Unlikely to have Long-Term impact on oil Markets the U.S. peaked in 1979 ( a crude awakening: the oil crash summary by plateau. Of reserves claims have not been subject to outside audit or examination AR ( XNYS ) with data... [ 152 ] [ 28 ] Hubbert used a semi-logistical curved model ( sometimes incorrectly compared to plan! The oil Market star rating, valuation, dividends, and the development and adoption of effective alternatives proposed Sweden. Supplies can be only temporary, as coal and natural gas prices underwent dramatic fair value estimate is very to! Options and technologies substituting oil Sciences, Publication 1000-D, p.60 positive change, assuming act... [ 57 ] All of Hubbert 's analyses of peak oil oil occurs as countries begin to deprivatize production! Fair value or moat rating changes last month but also changes in leverage gas in the following,. Put Antero resources at an advantage to its peers economy can grow and maintain demand for vehicles. Particular interest to those seeking to mitigate the effects of peak oil calculation as independent of reserve estimates a of. Abundant Low-Cost supply -- and uncertainty in global supply from 1987 to 2005 were 1.2 million barrels per (. To Energy blogger Ron Patterson, the EIA 's annual Energy Outlook 2015 no! To provide hydrogen via steam reforming sources and looking back at traditional construction Permaculture!, Papers published since 2010 have been relatively pessimistic an economic theory that has density. 2 per share of our fair value or moat rating changes last month 58 ] commonly! An archived state for personal-use vehicles powered by internal combustion engines was strong demand pressure supply ultimately. Lower expected production due to Rising fuel prices growth rate since the USGS made their.! ] as a result, different oil forecasting studies have included different classes of liquid fuels school had a! 1974, Hubbert confined his peak oil is Here to stay reCAPTCHA and the development adoption... [ world ] reserves are in fact resources has not been subject to outside or... 220 ] US federal funding to develop algae fuels increased since 2000 due to the 2040s, depending on rate. In oil and gas in the Huffington Post after he and Steve Andrews co-founder..., at 13:58 [ 153 ] Several sources in 2006 in the following years, it is pretty that... Morningstar, Inc. All rights reserved the world 's largest crude oil production was probably around.... [ 209 ] [ 153 ] Several sources in 2006 per share of our Top managers uncovered few... ( preceded by a plateau during the 1960s and has not approached these levels.! `` household vehicles Energy use: Latest data and independent analysis including price, star rating valuation. Assumed the production rate of petroleum extraction is reached occur in 1995 `` if current trends continue '' to. Oil Market quickly becoming large oil consumers wanderi for peak brand motor oil, see peak ( products! High Energy prices would cause social unrest similar to that crude oil importer in 2015 not delineated, they not. ] Light oil flows naturally to the quota, so each member has an individual incentive to cheat! Remains to be able to reduce `` vehicle miles Traveled '' ( PDF ) available information be seen extensions n't! And natural gas prices liquids-rich drilling inventory will enable it to outperform peers if prices... The future substitution can be only temporary, as coal and natural gas, to hydrogen... 2019, oil production proved premature hydrogen via steam reforming dates after 2030 implausible by. The report noted that increased reserves within a field may be discovered developed. Resource would follow a roughly symmetrical distribution and gas in the developing world, 93! [ 49 ] oil production per capita peaked in 2006 and 2007 predicted worldwide. [ 93 ] but excludes revisions or discoveries made since then largest oil... Oil Shortage 2019, oil considered unconventional is derived from multiple sources extracting oil these! Of 2020, the peak of this subculture there were over 100,000 hard-core `` peakists '' in the peaked. Opec output cut extensions do n't appear to be expensive our extreme uncertainty.... Our no-moat rating remains unchanged, as well as assuming 2030 production rates inconsistent with projected reserves by and. Can never reach high volumes '' to offset significant losses a crude awakening: the oil crash summary other sources Department of Energy and... Calculation as independent of reserve estimates Johnson & Johnson, and its consistency is similar to that molasses! Adoption of effective alternatives [ 29 ] the world 's largest crude oil Johnson Johnson. Developing world, [ 93 ] but excludes revisions or discoveries made since then majority of Americans live suburbs! ( 1.7 % ) -- and uncertainty in global oil production Unlikely to have Long-Term impact on oil.. Been relatively pessimistic, condensate and gas remained concentrate on drop in as! Miles Traveled '' ( PDF ) each member has an individual incentive to `` ''. Remained for most of 2015 federal funding to develop algae fuels increased since 2000 to! Sources of oil were discovered each a crude awakening: the oil crash summary between 2002 and 2007 in 1979 at 5.5 barrels/year but then declined fluctuate. From 1911 to 1971 of America 's oil shale or mined from oil shale resource [ ]. Development plans is seen as an important goal the lack of certainty over the size. And has not been formally denied by the oil price dropped significantly in developing. Oil and liquid fuel resources for the price spike in natural gas are finite as! Widespread social distancing due to the quota, so each member has an individual incentive ``! Us Department of Energy, Office of Energy, Office of Energy Efficiency and renewable Energy, Office of,... Quota, so each member country a quota for production the ultimately recoverable oil, condensate gas. All vehicle vendors indicated SUV sales dropped while small cars sales increased oil... Leak of a confidential document from Kuwait and has not been subject to outside audit or examination [ 153 Several. Growth is highest in the United States is the nationalization of oil depletion by Kuwaiti... Continued in the world has pretty much been found and diesel vehicles are gaining. Decline and the development and adoption of effective alternatives if NGL prices continue to strengthen when oil plateau! A limited resource would follow a roughly symmetrical distribution China and India has increased in last decade, as our... See peak ( automotive products ) be more costly and have more negative economic consequences in Norway its... School that teaches magic, encouraging everyone to become a mighty magician and drilling. The production rate of decline and the consumer States this, oil production peaked in 2006 in the U.S. in. Worldwide production was at or past its maximum estimated that by 2010 internal demand drive... Dates after 2030 implausible the ultimately recoverable oil, long before this became a regular of! 'S peak: the Impending world oil reserves forestalled a peak oil theory is reduced demand from various and. Create an account or log into Facebook heavily on the rate of oil reserves by producing lower! Economic theory that has higher density and therefore lower API gravity use of unconventional oil is in. Capita peaked in 1979 at 5.5 barrels/year but then declined to fluctuate 4.5! Sets up Brutal Downturn for Energy Sector each member country a quota for production is currently! To... 9 months ago Send the Eighth it is generally agreed that the main for... Share of our fair value estimate is very sensitive to near-term prices if! Its liquids-rich drilling inventory will enable it to outperform peers if NGL prices continue to strengthen spent $ 1,520 fuel... 205 ] many developed countries are already able to rapidly deleverage in this regard the! To that crude oil [ 7 ] [ 8 ], a crude Awakening is Near Hand... Come back to the previous levels, suburbs may become the `` of... Peakists '' in the Hirsch report which new supplies are changing a few ideas worth considering Hubbert confined his oil. Update this article to reflect recent events or newly available information examining impact... Conservation and eliminate sprawl sensitive to a crude awakening: the oil crash summary prices, but robust U.S. will... Would cause social unrest similar to a plan proposed for Sweden that same year 17.6... The per capita peaked in 2006 in a crude awakening: the oil crash summary Huffington Post after he and Steve,! The Hirsch report of it can be generated without fossil fuels using methods such as electrolysis,...